LITTLE
CHILDREN
It is hard to figure
out where to start discussing Little Children.
It is easy enough
to say that it is the best American film of 2006 to date, since it is.
To say that this
film is one of the great sophomore efforts of all time (by director/co-writer
Todd Field) is no overstatement. And to write that Tom Perrotta
is fortunate that this only the second film made from one of his books,
since seven years after Election this is one of the few films
worthy of being a successor to that unexpected achievement, would be
fair, but too easy.
One could easily
assert that Little Children is the film that Ang Lee and
Alan Ball and Robert Redford and Paul Thomas Anderson
and even Woody Allen have been trying to make for a long
time. (Allen had the most success with the magnificent Crimes &
Misdemeanors.) Others, like Alejandro Inarritu and Steven
Soderbergh and Alexander Payne and Cameron Crowe and
Jim Brooks and the Coen Brothers are working on similar
canvases, but are too interested in entertaining to go somewhere quite
this dry and relentless (though they often come close and achieve greatness
on different levels). I love me some Malick, but he wants to let the
wind blow through our hair and to allow us to reflect on ourselves even
as we watch his movies. In England & Ireland, Jim Sheridan
and Alan Parker and Neil Jordan and Mike Leigh have
gone here and have probably come closer to this work in defining their
cultures than American filmmakers previously have. But the one filmmaker
whose voice is clear and clean in Little Children, aside from
Todd Field, is Stanley Kubrick's. This is not an imitation
(in spite of some very specific steals), but Field's breathed in and
assimilated extension of The Master's Voice.
But I still haven't
told you much about the movie.
As much as I want
to offer an easy description of the film, it's not a possibility. Confirming
that is New Line's terrific, but narrow, trailer for the movie. They
decided, understandably, to focus on "The Affair" in the film.
But man, I am here to tell you
it's just the appetizer.
I keep finding myself
singing Pete Seeger's "Little Boxes," currently enjoying
renewed fame as the theme song of Showtime's first great non-niche series,
Weeds, to myself when I think of this film...
"Little
boxes on the hillside,
Little boxes made of ticky-tacky,
Little boxes, little boxes,
Little boxes, all the same.
There's a green
one and a pink one
And a blue one and a yellow one
And they're all made out of ticky-tacky
And they all look just the same."
There is something
about the light heart behind that song and the simple understanding
of human nature that connects to the film for me (much more than the
TV series, actually). We are not all the same. And none of us is all
that different. We are all made of the same ticky-tacky.
In Little Children's
case, "we" are stay-at-home mothers and stay-at-home-fathers
and working moms and working dads and convicted sex offenders and the
mothers of convicted sex offenders and cops and the handicapped and
the emotionally handicapped and neighbors and of course, lots of little
children of many different ages.
We are all so unique.
We are all so different. Our decision-making is so inevitably passionate
and so inevitably rational.
This is the remarkable
power of Little Children. And, make no mistake, it will take
a lot of people more than a moment to get used to that power.
The film is very,
very funny, but audiences are afraid to laugh at a lot of the humor.
After all, how funny are cheating and perversion and mean-spiritedness
and outright stupidity? Very funny. But it's a Kubrickian humor
tough and more than a little shocking.
One of the devices
is a rather unexpected voiceover that is at first discomfiting, but
which clarifies its value as it continues. (The familiar voice is Will
Lyman, who does the voiceovers for Frontline on PBS
which, not so coincidentally, is the network the film's Kathy makes
docs for.) But Todd Field keeps the voiceover (which is almost
all directly out of the Perrotta book) within its own realm. It has
a sense of humor, but it never falls into comedy.
The most talked
about element of the film will be the convicted sex offender with a
proclivity for little children. But anyone who would call it "that
child molester movie" would be simplifying beyond reason. The character,
played by Jackie Earle Haley, comes home to his mother, played
by the amazing Phyllis Somerville. (She should be Oscar bait.
Breathtaking work.) And this character is so complex and real that it
really stands up there with some of the greats. This man knows what
he is and he knows what he isn't. And he struggles. And his mother struggles.
And as tough as it is to watch at times without wincing, its truth is
profound.
Winslet rarely misses.
And her turn here is layered in ways you can't imagine even as you watch
it. She plays a character who thinks she knows her parameters
but until they are challenged, she doesn't. This probably should be
her Oscar winner.
Patrick Wilson
is surprisingly right in his role. Some have suggested that he is a
little too much the character
a little too easy to understand.
But I think it is daring to be that open.
And the most underappreciated
performance in those three fronting leads will surely be Jennifer
Connelly's. But it really is one of her best ever. She plays The
Perfect Woman. But as we all know, no one really is perfect. And while
we never get too much range from the character, Connelly breathes her
in a daring and unselfish way that I really admired. It's one of those
roles that feels so real that people won't realize how structured a
performance it is.
Todd Field
has made a big step as a director here. He has taken his In The Bedroom
skills and his passion for Kubrick and added his own twists of style
and skill. There isn't a shot in the movie that feels wrong. Whether
it's a table scene with four characters who are each in a completely
different place emotionally or a scene underwater meant to force/allow
us to see through the eyes of a sex offender or a satirical take on
football, Field uses the whole toolbox with assurance and detail. And
any time you get the feeling that maybe he got the wrong performance
out of someone, the reason why it is perfection is right around the
corner.
Little Children
is the first American masterpiece of 2006. We'll be chewing on this
one for a long time to come.
-
Email David Poland