A.O.
Scott
New
York Times
|
|
1
|
4
Months, 3 Weeks, and 2 Days |
|
2
|
Ratatouille |
|
3
|
There
Will Be Blood/Sweeney Todd |
|
4
|
I'm
Not There/Joe Strummer |
|
5
|
No
End in Sight/Terror's Advocate |
|
6
|
12:08
East of Bucharest / Live In Maid |
|
7
|
Into
the Wild/Diving Bell and the Butterfly |
|
8
|
The
Lives of Others/Michael Clayton |
|
9
|
The
Savages/Away From Her |
|
10
|
Knocked
Up/Superbad/Juno |
|
|
Stephen
Holden
New
York Times
|
|
1
|
There
Will Be Blood |
|
2
|
The
Lives of Others |
|
3
|
Diving
Bell and the Butterfly |
|
4
|
Persepolis |
|
5
|
Starting
Out in the Evening |
|
6
|
No
Country for Old Men |
|
7
|
Sweeney
Todd |
|
8
|
Atonement |
|
9
|
Across
the Universe |
|
10
|
Juno |
|
| |
|
|
Matt
Dentler
SxSW
Festival Producer
|
|
1
|
Diving
Bell and the Butterfly |
|
2
|
There
Will Be Blood |
|
3
|
Killer
of Sheep |
|
4
|
No
Country for Old Men |
|
5
|
The
King of Kong |
|
6
|
Persepolis |
|
7
|
In
the Shadow of the Moon |
|
|
Christopher
Kelly
Star
Telegram
|
|
1
|
The
Bourne Ultimatum |
|
2
|
4
Months, 3 Weeks, and 2 Days |
|
3
|
Ratatouille |
|
4
|
Once |
|
5
|
Michael
Clayton |
|
6
|
This
is England |
|
7
|
Diving
Bell and the Butterfly |
|
8
|
Alpha
Dog |
|
9
|
My
Kid Could Paint That |
|
10
|
No
Country for Old Men |
|
| |
|
|
Saul
Austerlitz
Boston
Globe
|
|
1
|
The
Lives of Others |
|
2
|
Ratatouille |
|
3
|
Eastern
Promises |
|
4
|
4
Months, 3 Weeks, and 2 Days |
|
5
|
No
End in Sight |
|
6
|
Michael
Clayton |
|
7
|
Offside |
|
8
|
I'm
Not There |
|
9
|
Before
the Devil Knows You're Dead |
|
10
|
Southland
Tales |
|
|
Bob
Longino
Atlantic
Journal Constitution
|
|
1
|
No
Country for Old Men |
|
2
|
Diving
Bell and the Butterfly |
|
3
|
Atonement |
|
4
|
There
Will Be Blood |
|
5
|
The
Bourne Ultimatum |
|
6
|
Knocked
Up |
|
7
|
Assassination
of Jesse James |
|
8
|
Lars
and the Real Girl |
|
9
|
Gone
Baby Gone |
|
10
|
Ratatouille |
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
1
|
There
Will Be Blood |
|
2
|
Zodiac |
|
3
|
No
Country for Old Men |
|
4
|
Persepolis |
|
5
|
The
Host |
|
6
|
Exiled |
|
7
|
The
King of Kong |
|
8
|
The
Darjeeling Limited |
|
9
|
Black
Snake Moan |
|
10
|
Hot
Fuzz |
|
 |
Manohla
Dargis
New
York Times
|
|
1
|
There
Will Be Blood/Zodiac |
|
2
|
Into
Great Silence/I'm Not There |
|
3
|
Killer
of Sheep/Bourne Ultimatum |
|
4
|
Eastern
Promises/Michael Clayton |
|
5
|
4
Months, 3 Weeks & 2 Days/I Don't Want To Sleep Alone |
|
6
|
Lady
Chatterley/Colossal Youth |
|
7
|
Monika/Superbad/Southland
Tales |
|
8
|
No
End in Sight/Before the Devil Knows You're Dead |
|
9
|
This
is England/The Savages/Year of the Dog |
|
10
|
Paprika/The
Host/The Kingdom |
|
| |
|
|
Richard
Roeper
Chicago
Sun Times
|
|
1
|
American
Gangster/The Brave One |
|
2
|
Breach/Charlie
Wilson's War |
|
3
|
Eastern
Promises/Gone BabyGone |
|
4
|
Grindhouse/The
Hoax |
|
5
|
Into
the Wild/Juno |
|
6
|
Knocked
Up/The Lookout |
|
7
|
Michael
Clayton/A Mighty Heart |
|
8
|
No
Country for Old Men/Once |
|
9
|
Paris
Je T'aime/Superbad |
|
10
|
Sweeney
Todd/Zodiac
|
|
 |
Jason
Anderson
Eye
Weekly
|
|
1
|
Lady
Chatterley |
|
2
|
Syndromes
and a Century |
|
3
|
There
Will Be Blood |
|
4
|
Zodiac |
|
5
|
Paprika |
|
6
|
Offside |
|
7
|
Black
Book |
|
8
|
Forever |
|
9
|
Ten
Canoes |
|
10
|
I'm
Not There |
|