Andrew
Sarris
New York Observer
|
|
1
|
Army of Shadows |
|
2
|
Volver
|
|
3
|
The
Departed |
|
4
|
Notes
on a Scandal |
|
5
|
Water
|
|
6
|
A
Prairie Home Companion |
|
7
|
Casino
Royale |
|
8
|
Find
Me Guilty |
|
9
|
Little
Miss Sunshine |
|
10
|
L'Enfant
|
|
 |
|
|
| - |
The
Black Dahlia |
| - |
Charlotte's
Web |
| - |
C.S.A.:
The Confederate States of America |
| - |
Duck
Season |
| - |
4
|
| - |
Miami
Vice |
| - |
Neil
Young: Heart of Gold |
| - |
The
Proposition |
| - |
A
Prairie Home Companion |
| - |
Superman
Returns |
|
| |
|
|
Chuck
Stephens
Film Comment
|
| - |
The
Departed |
| - |
Little
Children |
| - |
A
Scanner Darkly |
| - |
Old
Joy |
| - |
Jackass
Number Two |
| - |
Battle
in Heaven |
| - |
4
|
| - |
I
Am a Sex Addict |
| - |
Le
Petit Lieutenant |
| - |
Woman
Is the Future of Man |
|
 |
David
Sterritt
Nat Society Of Film
Critics
|
|
1
|
Children of Men |
|
2
|
The
Good Shepherd |
|
3
|
The
Last King of Scotland |
|
4
|
A
Scanner Darkly |
|
5
|
Babel
|
|
6
|
Deliver
Us From Evil |
|
7
|
L'Enfant
|
|
8
|
A
Prairie Home Companion |
|
9
|
Marie
Antoinette |
|
10
|
Borat:
Cultural Learnings of America for Make Benefit Glorious Nation
of Kazakhstan |
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
1
|
Army of Shadows |
|
2
|
Inland
Empire |
|
3
|
Letters
From Iwo Jima |
|
4
|
Three
Times |
|
5
|
Duck
Season |
|
6
|
Mutual
Appreciation |
|
7
|
Old
Joy |
|
8
|
Fast
Food Nation |
|
9
|
The
Case of the Grinning Cat |
|
10
|
Sir!
No Sir! |
|
 |
|
|
|
1
|
Army
of Shadows |
|
2
|
Days of Glory |
|
3
|
Clean
|
|
4
|
Three
Times |
|
5
|
The
Queen |
|
6
|
Pan's
Labyrinth |
|
7
|
Casino
Royale |
|
8
|
The
Painted Veil |
|
9
|
A
Prairie Home Companion |
|
10
|
Shut
Up and Sing |
|
| |
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
1
|
Army
of Shadows |
|
2
|
Family
Law |
|
3
|
The
Death of Mr. Lazarescu |
|
4
|
Old
Joy |
|
5
|
The
Queen |
|
6
|
Iraq
in Fragments |
|
7
|
Venus
|
|
8
|
49
Up |
|
9
|
Our
Brand Is Crisis |
|
10
|
Lassie
|
|
 |
|
|
|
1
|
The
Departed |
|
2
|
Children
of Men |
|
3
|
United
93 |
|
4
|
Old
Joy |
|
5
|
Brick
|
|
6
|
Volver
|
|
7
|
L'Enfant
|
|
8
|
The
Devil and Daniel Johnston |
|
9
|
Neil
Young: Heart of Gold |
|
10
|
Half
Nelson |
|
| |
|
|
Armond
White
New York Observer
|
|
1
|
Broken Sky |
|
2
|
Neil
Young: Heart of Gold |
|
3
|
A
Prairie Home Companion |
|
4
|
World
Trade Center |
|
5
|
Nacho
Libre |
|
6
|
The
Promise |
|
7
|
Infamous
|
|
8
|
Akeelah
and the Bee |
|
9
|
Bobby
|
|
10
|
Running
Scared |
|
 |
Stephanie
Zacharek
Salon.com
|
|
1
|
Army of Shadows |
|
2
|
Days
of Glory |
|
3
|
Casino
Royale |
|
4
|
The
Queen |
|
5
|
Pan's
Labyrinth |
|
6
|
Dave
Chappelle's Block Party |
|
7
|
Marie
Antoinette |
|
8
|
Idlewild
|
|
9
|
The
Painted Veil |
|
10
|
A
Prairie Home Companion |
|
| |
|
|