Joe
Morgenstern
Wall Street Journal
|
|
1
|
Deliver
Us From Evil |
|
2
|
The
Departed |
|
3
|
The
History Boys |
|
4
|
The
Last King of Scotland |
|
5
|
Letters
From Iwo Jima |
|
6
|
Little
Miss Sunshine |
|
P
|
Pan's
Labyrinth |
|
8
|
The
Queen |
|
9
|
United
93 |
|
10
|
Volver |
|
 |
Sean
O'Connell
WBTV-3 Charlotte
|
|
1
|
United
93 |
|
2
|
The
Fountain |
|
3
|
Little
Miss Sunshine |
|
4
|
Dixie
Chicks: Shut Up & Sing |
|
5
|
The
Prestige |
|
6
|
Children
of Man |
|
7
|
V
for Vendetta |
|
8
|
Monster
House |
|
9
|
The
Good German/Brick |
|
10
|
Hard
Candy |
|
| |
|
|
Stephen
King
For Entertainment
Weekly
|
|
1
|
Pan's
Labyrinth |
|
2
|
United
93 |
|
3
|
The
Departed |
|
4
|
Casino
Royale |
|
5
|
The
Descent |
|
6
|
The
Illusionist |
|
7
|
Snakes
on a Plane |
|
8
|
Waist
Deep |
|
9
|
The
Three Burials of Melquiades Estrada |
|
10
|
The
World's Fastest Indian |
|
 |
|
|
|
1
|
Babel |
|
2
|
Bobby |
|
3
|
Borat |
|
4
|
Children
of Men |
|
5
|
The
Departed |
|
6
|
The
Last King of Scotland |
|
7
|
Letters
from Iwo Jima |
|
8
|
Little
Miss Sunshine |
|
9
|
The
Queen |
|
10
|
United
93 |
|
| |
|
|
James
Rocchi
Cinematical/CBS-5
San Francisco
|
|
1
|
Children
of Men |
|
2
|
Pan's
Labyrinth |
|
3
|
Jesus
Camp |
|
4
|
Deliver
Us From Evil |
|
5
|
Brick |
|
6
|
Half
Nelson |
|
7
|
Casino
Royale |
|
8
|
The
Queen |
|
9
|
Borat |
|
10
|
Why
We Fight |
|
 |
|
|
|
1
|
The
Departed |
|
2
|
Letters
from Iwo Jima |
|
3
|
The
Queen |
|
4
|
United
93 |
|
5
|
Little
Miss Sunshine |
|
6
|
Babel |
|
7
|
Pan's
Labyrinth |
|
8
|
Little
Children |
|
9
|
Thank
You For Smoking |
|
10
|
Notes
on a Scandal |
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
1
|
The
Departed |
|
2
|
Marie
Antoinette |
|
3
|
The
Queen |
|
4
|
Monkey
Warfare |
|
5
|
Cache |
|
6
|
Manufactured
Landscapes |
|
P
|
United
93 |
|
8
|
L'Enfant |
|
9
|
Borat |
|
10
|
Half
Nelson |
|
 |
Emanuel
Levy
Emanuellevy.com
|
|
1
|
Pan's
Labyrinth |
|
2
|
Letters
From Iwo Jima/Flags Of Our Fathers |
|
3
|
The
Lives of Others |
|
4
|
The
Departed |
|
5
|
The
Queen |
|
6
|
Little
Children |
|
7
|
Babel |
|
8
|
Volver/Death
of Mr. Lazarescu |
|
9
|
Borat |
|
10
|
Half
Nelson |
|
| |
|
|
Peter
Travers
Rolling Stone
|
|
1
|
The
Departed |
|
2
|
Dreamgirls |
|
3
|
Letters
from Iwo Jima/Flags of Our Fathers |
|
4
|
Volver |
|
5
|
Babel |
|
6
|
United
93 |
|
7
|
The
Queen |
|
8
|
Borat |
|
9
|
Little
Miss Sunshine |
|
10
|
Prairie
Home Companion |
|
|
|
|
|
1
|
Letters
From Iwo Jima |
|
2
|
Babel |
|
3
|
Blood
Diamond |
|
4
|
The
Departed |
|
5
|
The
Devil Wears Prada |
|
6
|
Flags
of our Fathers |
|
7
|
The
History Boys |
|
8
|
Little
Miss Sunshine |
|
9
|
Notes
on a Scandal |
|
10t
|
The
Painted Veil |
|
| |
|
|
| |
|
|
| |
|
|